A good Direct Drive wheel isn't just about generating strong forces. It's about receiving useful information from the game and being able to understand what the car is doing without having to guess.
After experimenting with different settings in several racing games, there are a few things worth discussing, particularly when it comes to force feedback filtering, damping and additional tactile feedback.
1. Force Feedback: More Isn't Always Better
When buying an expensive Direct Drive wheel, the natural temptation is to disable everything that might interfere with the original force feedback signal.
After all, why spend money on a powerful, responsive wheel if you're going to filter or dampen the information it receives?
However, there's a distinction between useful information and unwanted noise.
Force Feedback Filtering smooths rapid changes in the signal sent to the wheel. It can make the steering feel less nervous, but excessive filtering can also remove subtle details and reduce responsiveness.
Damping is different. It introduces resistance to wheel movement, generally depending on how quickly the wheel rotates. It can help control oscillations and make the steering feel more stable, but excessive damping can make the wheel feel unnecessarily heavy and less responsive.
My general approach is to preserve as much of the original feedback as possible and only introduce filtering or damping when there's a noticeable benefit.
For example, in F1, I prefer:
- FFB Filter: 1
- Dampener: OFF
The wheel feels responsive, and its weight changes according to the driving situation, including speed, braking and steering load. I don't feel the need to artificially increase resistance.
2. ACC: Finding the Right Balance
Assetto Corsa Competizione is a different experience, particularly when driving GT cars.
The steering naturally feels heavier than in Formula 1, but that doesn't mean the wheel should become unnecessarily difficult to move.
My intention is to make the steering feel a little more agile without sacrificing the information coming from the tyres.
Rather than immediately changing the FFB Filter, I would experiment with the hardware Dampener first.
For example, if using a Dampener value of 20, try reducing it gradually to 15, 10 and eventually OFF.
Keep the other settings unchanged during each test. This makes it easier to identify what actually improves the experience.
There are also several important settings on the ACC side:
- Gain: Adjust according to the car and avoid force feedback clipping.
- Minimum Force: 0% for a Direct Drive wheel.
- Damper: Start at 0%.
- Dynamic Damping: Start at 100%.
- Road Effects: Start at 0%.
- Frequency: 400 Hz.
- Steer Lock: 1080°.
- Steer Linearity: 1.00.
Road Effects deserves particular attention. ACC already provides feedback generated by its physics engine, including tyre forces, suspension behaviour and track irregularities. Road Effects adds another layer of surface-related sensations.
It isn't necessarily bad, but it can introduce additional vibration that doesn't always provide useful information.
On a capable Direct Drive wheel, I prefer starting at zero and experimenting with small values if I feel something is missing.
The objective isn't to make the wheel constantly vibrate. It's to understand what the car is doing.
3. Sim Racing vs Arcade-Oriented Racing Games
One of the most noticeable differences between proper racing simulators and more arcade-oriented games is how consistently the steering communicates what the car is doing.
In games such as:
- Assetto Corsa
- Assetto Corsa Competizione
- F1
- DiRT Rally 2.0
- EA SPORTS WRC
I generally have a good understanding of what the car is doing through the steering wheel. I can feel changes in grip, steering load and the behaviour of the car without constantly having to guess.
Forza Horizon 6 is considerably better than its predecessors in terms of force feedback, but I still find the relationship between steering input and vehicle behaviour less intuitive.
This isn't necessarily a matter of wheel strength. The way a game translates its vehicle physics into force feedback and steering response makes a considerable difference.
4. Forza Horizon 6: The Missing Physical Soft Lock
One particularly frustrating limitation is the lack of proper physical soft lock.
The virtual steering wheel reaches its maximum steering angle, but the physical wheel doesn't stop with it.
This creates a practical problem, especially when racing.
You can continue turning the physical wheel even though the virtual steering has already reached its limit. You're effectively adding steering input that does nothing.
The consequences are particularly noticeable when:
- Approaching tight corners.
- Making quick steering corrections.
- Unwinding the steering after a corner.
- Switching between cars with different steering ratios.
Soft lock is not simply an immersion feature. It provides an important physical reference that helps develop muscle memory and maintain control.
For now, experimenting with a fixed rotation such as 720° can be a compromise, although it cannot replace proper per-car soft lock.
Ideally, the game should communicate each vehicle's actual steering limit to the wheelbase.
5. Adding SimHub Tactile Feedback
Another interesting improvement is using separate tactile transducers, commonly called bass shakers, to complement the steering wheel.
I initially experimented with a single shaker under the seat. Adding a second source at the front made a surprisingly big difference.
The idea is simple: instead of reproducing everything through one shaker, separate the feedback according to where it originates.
My current approach is:
- Rear shaker: Mounted under the seat.
- Front shaker: Mounted under the pedals.
Using SimHub, different effects can be assigned to each location.
For example:
- Front wheel lockup and ABS intervention.
- Rear wheel lockup and traction loss.
- Front and rear suspension impacts.
- Kerb and surface effects.
This gives you additional information about which end of the car is experiencing an event.
It's important to understand that these are telemetry-driven effects, not necessarily the actual physical vibrations of individual tyres. SimHub translates the information provided by the game into tactile feedback.
Nevertheless, the additional spatial information is extremely useful.
6. Why I Prefer Subtle Tactile Feedback
The purpose of bass shakers isn't to turn the rig into a massage chair.
A powerful Direct Drive wheel, such as the Logitech G PRO, already produces enough force to transmit considerable vibration through the entire rig.
The shakers should complement the wheel, not compete with it.
I prefer keeping their intensity relatively low and assigning them specific responsibilities.
Think of the setup as three complementary sources of information:
- Steering wheel: Steering forces, tyre load, grip changes and vehicle behaviour.
- Front shaker: Additional information about front axle events.
- Rear shaker: Additional information about rear axle events.
The objective is to receive more useful information, not simply more vibration.
A rigid rig can also transmit vibrations quite effectively, so adding more shakers or constantly increasing their intensity isn't necessarily going to improve the experience.
For now, one shaker under the seat and another under the pedals should provide a very good starting point.
Final Thoughts
A good sim racing setup isn't about maximising every available setting.
It's about finding the right balance between responsiveness, steering weight, useful force feedback and additional tactile information.
I prefer a wheel that communicates what the car is doing naturally, without unnecessary filtering, artificial resistance or excessive effects.
The same philosophy applies to tactile feedback. A couple of well-positioned shakers with carefully selected effects can add considerably more useful information than a complicated setup that simply vibrates constantly.
Ultimately, the goal is simple: understand what the car is doing, react naturally and spend less time guessing.
- Log in to post comments
- 18 views